TWEETSTORM: TRON questions about claimed collateralization
source link: https://decentralize.today/tweetstorm-tron-facing-questions-about-its-claimed-collateraliszation-reservations-being-expressed/
Go to the source link to view the article. You can view the picture content, updated content and better typesetting reading experience. If the link is broken, please click the button below to view the snapshot at that time.
TWEETSTORM: TRON facing questions about its claimed collateralization, reservations being expressed!
TWEETSTORM is an occasional feature on decentralize.today where we share threads, mostly from Twitter, that we think deserve a wider audience, some are informative, some educational, some amusing and others yet are controversial...we dig these out for you so you don't have to!
1/ This is nuts @usddio @trondaoreserve & @trondao are deceiving the market with $USDD They are claiming that $USDD is collateralized at over 200% and this information is technically FALSE I'm gonna explain why
2/ According to their articles, they claim that collateral ratio is over 200% Let's check some data at https://tdr.org/#/ - $USDD supply = 667M - $TRX burnt = $667M = $USDD supply - Reserves = $787M - Collateral ratio = 218%
3/ Collateral ratio is defined as the ratio between the collateral and the issued stablecoin: Collateral ratio = Reserves / Total_USDD_issuance = 787 / 667 = 118% Huh? Why does the website show Collat. Ratio = 218% then?
4/ Well, they are considering the 8.29B $TRX burnt as collateral!
Let's review the math then Reserves + 8.29B $TRX burnt (= $USDD supply) = $787M + $667M = $1.454B Then Collat. Ratio = 1.454 / 0.667 = 218% Voilà!
5/ They use this formula: Collat. Ratio = (Reserves + TRX_burnt) / Total_USDD_supply then Collat. Ratio = Reserves / Total_USDD_supply + TRX_burnt / Total_USDD_supply If $TRX goes up in price. All good. If $TRX goes down in price, then TRX_burnt / Total_USDD_supply < 1
6/ "Well, they have other reserves..." ha! let's explore that as well Reserves = 13,040 $BTC + 240M $USDT + 1.9B $TRX Are you kidding me? You didn't have enough with claiming $TRX burnt is collateral. You also had to add it to the "Reserves"
7/ The same coin that is designed to be minted when $USDD is redeemed, is used as a Reserve Asset. Seems safe! "Hey $UST guys, it's okay, everything is backed by $LUNA tokens, we can't go to 0" Out of the $787M in the "Reserves", $156M are in the form of $TRX. A whopping 20%
8/ The Collat. ratio should be considered (1) without the burnt $TRX and (2) without $TRX in the Reserves - If we substract (1) --> Collat = $787M & Collat. Ratio = 118% - If we substract (1) and (2) --> Collat = $631M & Collat. Ratio = 95% Let's remember $USDD supply = $667M
9/ Let's then recapitulate. As per the formula they use: Collat. Ratio = Reserves / Total_USDD_supply + TRX_burnt / Total_USDD_supply - If $TRX goes down in price, then TRX_burnt / Total_USD_supply < 1 (it doesn't really make sense to even discuss this, but anyways)
10/ You have the other part of the equation: Reserves / Total_USDD_supply As you see, if you currently substract $TRX value from the Reserves, Reserve < Total_USDD_supply Can that happen? Well, if $USDD starts to be sold, more $TRX will be minted and the $TRX price will go down
11/ If it goes down enough so that $BTC + $USDT + $TRX < Total $USDD then you have a problem and $USDD would depeg So if $TRX price goes up, all good. If $TRX price goes down, not that good. Does that remind you of something?
12/ Summarizing: They claim to have a 218% collateral ratio, out of which: - 100% is the $TRX burnt to mint $USDD- 24% is $TRX in Reserves (the asset involved in the minting / burning mechanism) Real collateral is 118% Substracting $TRX from the Reserve, Collat. Ratio = 95%
https://nitter,net/resdegen/status/1533540958733754369?s=12&t=XMdjisQc6Bf0qIwpDfuVmg
Recommend
About Joyk
Aggregate valuable and interesting links.
Joyk means Joy of geeK