Silent changes to Western Digital’s budget SSD may lower speeds by up to 50%
source link: https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2021/08/silent-changes-to-western-digitals-budget-ssd-may-lower-speeds-by-up-to-50/
Go to the source link to view the article. You can view the picture content, updated content and better typesetting reading experience. If the link is broken, please click the button below to view the snapshot at that time.
SSD, more like SAD —
Silent changes to Western Digital’s budget SSD may lower speeds by up to 50%
Most people wouldn't notice most of the time, but that doesn't make it OK.
Andrew Cunningham - 8/26/2021, 10:30 AM
Western Digital's WD Blue SN550 budget SSD is a well-reviewed popular NVMe device that has regularly shown up on various sites' "best SSD" lists since it was released at the tail-end of 2019. The drive uses a four-lane PCI Express 3.0 interface and was novel for being able to perform better than SATA SSDs for about the same amount of money.
But that may be changing, thanks to quiet behind-the-scenes component changes: Chinese site Expreview (via Tom's Hardware and ExtremeTech) says that a newer version of the drive manufactured in July 2021 was writing data at speeds of about 390MB per second after the drive's cache had filled up. According to Expreview, that's about half the speed of older versions of the SN550; Tom's Hardware measured speeds of about 610MB per second during a sustained write test on the original SN550, so the exact amount of performance degradation may vary. Because both the old and new versions of the SN550 use the same SSD controller, it seems likely that the slowdown is being caused by inferior NAND flash.
Modern SSDs typically pair a large amount of slower NAND flash (for capacity) and a smaller cache of faster flash memory (for the peak speeds advertised on the box). Depending on the SSD, this cache memory is designed to sustain anywhere between a few gigabytes' and a few dozen gigabytes' worth of writes before it has to fall back on the slower flash. Most of the time, you'll never notice the drive slowing down, because you're not going to fill the cache up all the way by using your computer for basic browsing, office work, or even photo editing.
AdvertisementThe people who will notice are professional video editors who are regularly exporting, copying, and moving huge 4K video files around all day. It's normal not to get an SSD's advertised peak performance 100 percent of the time, but for a drive to perform substantially worse than it performed in thorough, professional reviews is misleading at best.
Sourcing components from multiple suppliers is common practice when manufacturing computers, phones, tablets, and the parts that go in them; if you can get a thing from multiple places, then slowdowns or interruptions in manufacturing at any one supplier is less likely to disrupt the flow of finished products, and the competition between suppliers can keep your costs down. But just as important is making sure that the components you're sourcing all perform more or less the same, lest you create a "lottery" system where some buyers (and all reviewers) get the "good" version of your product while others get stuck with poorer-than-expected performance.
SSD-makers changing components without updating their model numbers or spec sheets is unfortunately common—Tom's Hardware has a long rundown of examples. Sometimes, end users do benefit from component changes, like when SSD manufacturers change out older flash memory for improved flash with better specs. But in other cases, as with the SN550 and Adata's XPG SG8200 Pro, changes made to cut costs or simplify production end up hurting performance instead.
This isn't the first time in recent history that Western Digital has been caught playing fast and loose with specs. Its hard drive division has both fudged the rotational speed of some of its drives and has tried to sell slower-performing Shingled Magnetic Recording (or SMR) drives in its WD Red NAS drive lineup, only to backtrack later and rebrand them.
We've reached out to Western Digital to follow up on the original reporting; we'll update this story if we receive any new details.
Recommend
-
31
Western Digital has released a hotfix to resolve a serious authentication bypass vulnerability in the My Cloud product line which permits attackers to hijack and take full control of a vulnerable device. The tec...
-
49
Storage company's core project joins the GitHub undead
-
42
SweRV RISC-V core from Western Digital This repository contains the SweRV core design RTL License By contributing to this project, you agree that your contribution is governed by
-
41
README.md SweRV RISC-V core from Western Digital This repository contains the SweRV core design RTL License By contributing to this pro...
-
48
海淘手慢无:WD MY BOOK 桌面移动硬盘 10TB ，该优惠商品正在美国亚马逊特价出售，是具有高性价比的海淘产品。
-
20
Western Digital 端出 WD Black PCIe Gen4 x4 SSD、PCIe x8 AIC SSD 以及 Thunderbolt 3 DockWestern Digital 的 WD Black 家族在今日發表數款新品，其中包含公司第一款 PCIe Gen4 M.2 SSD、PCIe Gen3 SSD 以及第一款 Thunderbolt Dock；WD...
-
10
Western Digital 推出 USB 3.2 Gen2 x2 版本的 SanDisk Extreme Pro Portable SSD v2Western Digital 旗下品牌 SanDisk 較早之前更新了 Extreme Portable SSD 產品線，除了 Extreme Portable SSD 外，還有 Extreme Pro Protable SSD 系列產...
-
14
Worry-Free Recording When You Need It Designed to record for up to 20,000 hours
-
4
Western Digital caught swapping lower-grade NAND into budget SSD Not so solid state after all By
-
7
Make GPUs affordable again — Asus will lower some GPU prices up to 25% following tariff changes It's not the end of the GPU shortage, but it's a promising sign. ...
About Joyk
Aggregate valuable and interesting links.
Joyk means Joy of geeK